So they succeeded. Microsoft managed to pull me back over to WMP from iTunes with their
latest v10 release.
I actually had to argue with myself for a few minutes before I ditched iTunes. It was a tough choice. The biggest reason I moved from WMP9 to iTunes earlier was the clean, simplistic organization of the iTunes media library. Plus, the all-in-one design of iTunes for ripping, burning and managing won me over in an instant.
Now WMP10 is back with a very slick new interface, and some neat new features. Is it really that much better than iTunes? I don't think so, but here are some of the reasons why I switched back:
-
Responsiveness: iTunes always had this irritating delay everytime it was launched...on every machine that I've tried. It almost seemed like XP's prefetching feature, which works wonders for most other apps, did nothing for iTunes. I don't know why. WMP10 is fast...fast as in instantaneous. Click the icon, and it's up and running. Tagging large groups of mp3 files together also does not cause that hideous lag in WMP like it did in iTunes.
-
Resource-usage: Less memory and CPU usage. A huge number of Windows users hated iTunes for it's resource hogging when it first came out. They still do. I didn't care before, since it was, for me, the best player there was, and I was prepared to face the resource hit for it. Now there's WMP10...look at the next point.
-
Organization and Features: Quite simply, WMP10 does almost everything iTunes can (bar Rendezvous LAN sharing...I'll come to that later), and more. The media library can be made to look exactly like iTunes if you like...the same clean, simple layout. Even the rip and burn features have become extremely simplified. WMP10 rips high-bitrate MP3s like iTunes too now, in addition to WMA encoding, by the way.
Other less important reasons, but factors that counted, nonetheless:
-
Native Windows look-and-feel: WMP10 looks like a native Windows app. iTunes (and Quicktime, for that matter) look completely out of place in the Windows environment, especially when it's not all skinned to look like OS X. ;)
-
Availability of skins, plugins and extra visualizations: Quite self-explanatory, I think.
-
The music stores and portable media player sync: Ah, this has come up time and again. To beat a dead horse, I don't like Apple's restrictive policies. I don't like closed systems. WMP10 integrates with multiple music stores and syncs with 70+ portable media devices. iTunes? iTMS-iTunes-iPod only. Apple, Apple, Apple.
The one feature I'll miss from iTunes (which is why I'll leave it installed) is LAN sharing. This was a beautiful feature, but ever since I've been out of the university residence halls, I haven't had a chance to use it - there's just no shared music on any of the networks I connect to now.