I finally got around to testing the
Ubuntu 5.04 RC "Hoary Hedgehog" Live CD today, and I was pleasantly surprised by how well it ran.
I've been out of the Linux scene for several months now, and
Arch Linux 0.6 was the last distro I had running on my notebook. I've tried pretty much every other "major" distro in the not-so-distant past, but I've never seen a single one that worked as well as Ubuntu right out-of-the-box.
This is the first and only distro that was able to detect
and install my wireless card with no user intervention (it's an internal Intel PRO/Wireless 2200BG MiniPCI adapter, by the way). In fact, every single piece of hardware in the system, including my external USB 2.0 hard drive, was automatically detected and installed. I was pretty amazed. The out-of-the-box experience for new users has always been quite poor and problematic in most Linux distros, and it's great to see that the
Canonical folks have taken a step in the right direction.
Of course, this aspect of the Ubuntu "experience" will obviously vary according to individual hardware configurations, so your mileage may vary. But there are other little things that are quite nice as well - most notably the update service and the Synaptic Package Manager (derived from Debian). The former is similar to the Automatic Update feature in XP or the Software Update feature in OS X. The latter is a way to connect to a large software repository from which the user can download and install additional applications. It's a great feature, and my short experience with it was excellent - the process was smooth and clean, and dependencies were automatically taken care of. Beyond that, I'd say Ubuntu is pretty much like any other recent, major Linux distro.
Although I've worked quite a bit with Linux systems in the past, I was looking at Ubuntu purely from a newbie's perspective...I wanted to see how comfortable someone would be had they never seen or used a Linux system before, and even from the limited experience I had playing around with it for just less than an hour, I can see that Canonical has the right idea. This is the direction every Linux distro needs to take if it hopes to become a major player in the desktop OS arena.